Join WAN
Review

Tracce di Classe podcast on Sergey Bodrunov’s book “Noonomy”

The YouTube channel Tracce di Classe (Class Traces) has released a new video podcast, “Noonomy: Beyond Capitalism – An Economy at the Service of Humanity”, devoted to Professor Sergey Bodrunov’s book “Noonomy”. Selected excerpts from the podcast are available on the WAN YouTube channel.

The episode, hosted by Luca Placidi, features Sandro Teti, owner and director of the Rome-based publishing house Sandro Teti Editore, and Giorgio Brera, an industry expert and technical design specialist.

Giorgio Brera has more than 35 years of experience in developing and managing complex engineering projects. A graduate of the Faculty of Political Science at the University of Milan, where he specialised in political and administrative management, he combines his technical background with a long-standing interest in political science, socialist economic systems and enterprise reform.

YouTube channel Tracce di Classe (Class Traces).


NOONOMY: Beyond Capitalism – Economics in the Service of Man | Sandro Teti and Giorgio Brera


Luca Placidi: Hello again, dear audience! Today I'll start by introducing our guests: this is Sandro Teti, from Sandro Teti Editore Publishing House. Sandro, welcome back! 

Sandro Teti: Thank you for the invitation.

Luca Placidi: We also have Giorgio Brera. He's a political scientist, economist, and expert in renewable energy and gas. Giorgio, thank you for joining us today!

Giorgio Brera: Thank you for having me. 

Luca Placidi: So, today we have gathered to talk about a book. Basically, this book wasn't released recently: it has been on sale for several years already. We are talking about the book titled “Noonomy” by Sergey Bodrunov.  It describes a different view of the world, a different model of social organization. Today we will also try to figure out what exactly noonomy is.

In my view, this concept draws heavily on Marxism and develops its ideas. But the most interesting thing is this: when I first read this book, I was particularly intrigued by one point: why do new worldviews essentially emerge only in the East? I believe we need to give serious thought to this question.

So, are we in the West no longer capable of inventing anything new, of going beyond what we see around us and have long taken for granted? For example, social relations of production as we know them today, in the form they have taken, and so on.

And, as I see it, there are two key questions here. First, we need to understand what new worldviews are emerging in other countries, especially in the East. And second, we need to understand why countries like Russia remain capable of independently understanding the world intellectually and culturally, while we in the West have essentially lost this ability entirely. So, Giorgio, I'd like to start with you, if you don't mind. The thing is, our listeners are probably asking the same questions I did when I first encountered this book. People see the title "Noonomy" and immediately ask themselves: what exactly is this? How does this concept fit into our familiar picture of the world, and how does it relate to our everyday lives? Let's start with the essentials.

Giorgio Brera: Let me take a brief step back to explain how the idea of ​​noonomy originated.

Well, the term itself is scientific: it comes from Greek. To answer your first question, I'd like to recall an idea that Tommaso Padoa-Schioppa expressed in 2010, the significance of which I didn't consider at the time. Looking back now, I realize that this idea helps explain why certain worldviews emerge in the East.

In 2010, Padoa-Schioppa stated: "Today, in continental Europe, a comprehensive program of structural reforms must encompass the pension system, healthcare, the labor market, education, and other areas. However, all these reforms must be guided by a single principle: weakening the protective system that, throughout the 20th century, gradually shielded individuals from direct confrontation with the harsh side of life, with the vicissitudes of fate, with the consequences of their own shortcomings and virtues - whether as punishment or reward."

So, it turns out that the idea was put forward that people should return to harsh living conditions. To put it simply, noonomy is the complete opposite of what Padoa-Schioppa theorised. Noonomy is an economy that centers on the individual, their development, their well-being, and their life in this world. It turns out that in the West, we had people like these who theoretically justified the need to relearn how to live poorly - and they succeeded.

In the East, these ideas were arrived at after a double failure, and it's important to remember this. Bodrunov began as a mathematician, but then turned to issues of socialist planning - just as mechanisms designed to make the system more flexible were being introduced. The Soviet planning system was not sufficiently effective, and similar problems arose throughout the world; let's recall perestroika: there were certain objective difficulties. Then, with the introduction of the market economy - the "Shock Doctrine," as Klein would call it - in the early 1990s, the failures of the market itself became apparent.

It is from these difficult but important reflections - for we learn primarily from our own experience - that Bodrunov begins to derive the fundamental principles of a different economic model, noonomy, which centers on human well-being.

Obviously, all of this is only possible under certain conditions, which are developing between the 2010s and 2020s. So, he's talking about a new industrial society of the second generation, that is, the introduction of machines, including artificial intelligence. These are tools that help people work more efficiently. But (and I will press this point) they should be used not to increase profits, but to improve the quality of people's working lives.

Luca Placidi: So, Giorgio, everything's clear here. But I'd like to explore one interesting issue with you - what are the differences here? There's another school of thought, for example, the American technogeek scene, associated, in particular, with Peter Thiel. While they also express similar ideas, they ultimately arrive at a completely different, reactionary, and opposing view of the world. That is, they also, so to speak, argue that the application of technology in society can lead to improvements.

The problem is that the key element of noonomy, in my view, unlike that of American technogeeks - and here I'd like you to understand the difference- is as follows: at the center of noonomy is a worldview organized around the individual, and above all, it's a worldview that, so to speak, is about organizing collective productive potential based on the resources that humans have managed to develop for the common good. So, what exactly are these differences, and how do you think they can be distinguished? After all, some of our listeners might say, "But those on the other side are talking about that too."

Giorgio Brera: Well, let's say both yes and no. It's important to remember Bodrunov's education and his background. For example, turning to Karl Marx, to Mavr, he saw the implementation of innovative systems...if we reread the Grundrisse, we'll find that Marx says technological development should relieve workers from dangerous and repetitive tasks. Thus, there is this line of thought - our line - whereunder Bodrunov draws the classic distinction between economy as such and what we call economics, which the ancient Greeks called chrematistics, the art of getting rich. And here, too, we see that Peter Thiel and others lack a focus on solidarity. This, in my view, is the key difference: whenever we see economics failing to consider the well-being of others, we encounter an economics that treats others either as a source of profit or as a tool to be sacrificed.

This is a very important point, which stems from the collectivist tradition you mentioned. However, we also encounter similar ideas in Confucian thought: the head of the family should care for the well-being of the family, and if the family is properly organized, this principle extends to the province and then to the state.

It turns out that we live in conditions of extreme individualism. Everything is possible for us. Moreover, we can say that the greatness of modern thinkers and the scale of brainwashing to which we have been subjected for the last thirty years lies in the fact that all responsibility is shifted to the person himself, and he is told: if you don’t succeed in anything, then it’s your own fault. That is, we managed to make people feel guilty that they could not win in an obviously one-sided game. In my opinion, this is the essence of this whole idea.

The tools and technologies are, of course, the same: a CNC machine remains a CNC machine in Milan, in Shanghai, and in Leningrad, but it all depends on the purpose for which it's used. The technology, however, remains neutral. Technology develops in a specific direction in accordance with the interests that guide people. Noonomy establishes certain checklists: we are dealing with an economic theory that proposes establishing verifiable criteria to determine whether we are acting correctly.

Let me explain with a specific example: in our usual understanding of economics, everything is going well if a company's turnover and profitability are growing. Bodrunov, however, suggests paying attention to the external effects of this activity: for example, growing environmental pollution and the working conditions of people. Take Amazon workers, for example. Their working conditions might seem like paradise compared to those of Charlie in Modern Times. Remember the worker who ends up having to eat using a special machine designed to save time?

So, by studying labor processes and regulating working hours, Amazon became an extremely profitable company, but it achieved this profitability at the expense of hyper-exploitation of its workers. Therefore, the quality of life for Amazon employees is certainly not good.

 Luca Placidi: Absolutely.

Giorgio Brera: I'd like to quote Joan Robinson. She said, "The misery of being exploited by capitalists is nothing compared to the misery of not being exploited at all." In other words, Robinson meant that if you don't work, if you don't engage in productive activity, then this will undoubtedly have a negative impact on your situation.

In my opinion, Bodrunov thought a lot about what had happened in his country over the past forty to fifty years. He saw the shortcomings of first one system, then another. Bodrunov, a mathematician (and we must remember that he is not an economist), tried, to paraphrase the famous saying, "Economics is too serious a thing to be entrusted to economists," to solve the equation like a true mathematician. In other words, Bodrunov didn't ask the question, as most economists do -how to maximize return on investment - but how to build a society where people will be happy.  Of course, this is an ongoing process. We shouldn't think that we'll introduce noonomy today and everyone will become happy tomorrow. Noonomy is a path, and while economics evaluates only individual aspects of life, noonomy looks at the issue from a different perspective: how the introduction of technology affects people's well-being and how it can be used to build a better society.

To draw a parallel, something similar can often be found in the slogans of the Chinese Communist Party, which proclaim: "What do you want to achieve? We want to build a moderately prosperous society." For everyone, beyond question. This is the primary value of this idea; this is what captivated me, and for this I owe a debt of gratitude to Sandro Teti, a courageous publisher who translates and publishes works that no one else would have attempted to take on. I was impressed that someone had finally emerged who was once again asking the question: is it possible to be happy in a sea of ​​misery? In my view, it is a dignified life and an economy that fosters such a life that we should all strive for.

Luca Placidi: There's another point, too. I haven't read the book in its entirety yet; I'm currently reading it alongside other books. Overall, there's one aspect that's noticeable from the very beginning and quite clearly articulated: the interpenetration of culture and technology, characteristic of noonomy, which, in my view, distinguishes it from the Western model proposed, for example, by Thiel and his associates. In other words, technology is not an end in itself. Technology should, so to speak, set the conditions under which development can occur, but the cultural system must ultimately determine the direction for our development and use of these technologies.

This, it seems to me, reveals a certain worldview that could be called Greco-Western. After all, what this project strives for is the notion of the common good, and therefore the good of the community.

The American world, the tech environment of Silicon Valley, lacks this aspect, by contrast. It seems that they are simply developing tools designed either for profit or, paradoxically - if we follow Thiel's own ethic - for further militarization of the American state. In other words, technology is used in the interests of the state to ultimately ensure American hegemony on the world stage, based on US power.

I believe, one of the key aspects of noonomy, which it so well elucidates, is the historical nature of social relations and economic processes. Giorgio, I have one last question for you, after which I'll hand over to Sandro. I'd like to hear your opinion: noonomy, in my view, clearly demonstrates that social relations and economic processes must be viewed in their historical development. The way I see it, the key aspect that noonomy captures well is the historical nature of social relations and economic processes. In other words, we assume that the world is constantly evolving and changing, that nothing is immutable. Therefore, given this evolution and our progress, we must strive to use our skills and knowledge to improve the lives of those around us.

You rightly draw parallels with both China and Confucianism, since they share a similar approach in many ways. Here, however, I constantly hear all sorts of nonsense that essentially leads to existing social and economic relations being perceived as something natural. That is, in the world we live in, the idea of ​​anything beyond the capitalist mode of production, anything that transcends the ordinary law of supply and demand or the notion of the market as an independent entity, seems completely unthinkable, almost impossible. To my mind, this is where noonomy drives a wedge, so to speak, because it suggests that technology should be used for the development of humanity itself and to improve existing social environment.

This means we must share with each other and strive to live as well as possible, because humanity has already created technologies that were previously unimaginable. These technologies could reduce working hours and, theoretically speaking, improve everyone's lives, but in practice, we use them in ways that, paradoxically, instead of uniting people, they further divide society.

In Western countries, technological progress often results in job losses. For example, the introduction of artificial intelligence into production and labor processes leads to layoffs. Why? Because companies seek to extract even more surplus value from those employees who remain on staff, further exploiting their labor.

In my opinion, it is this aspect that points to the need for, so to speak, a collectivist approach to managing the economy and the state itself.

Giorgio Brera: Luca, you've clearly grasped the purpose of noonomy, and with your permission I'll outline its fundamental tenets. It's a unique synthesis of Greek and Marxist thought. It's worth remembering that Bodrunov's education was largely based on the study of Marxist texts. Karl Marx advocated a shorter workday to free up time for other pursuits.

Work has always been perceived as something negative, a necessity without which society could not develop, although it is not an end in itself, but merely a means. It allows us to provide for ourselves and, therefore, to live. But the primary goal of a person is intellectual and cultural development. In other words, we must give meaning to our own lives.

Economics, of course, has always existed, but in previous historical eras it was not so important. Not because economics played no role back then…

Here is an example. The Arena di Verona is a great example of public investment that has paid off over time: it continues to attract thousands upon thousands of people to its performances. After all, people should have the opportunity to develop culturally and enrich themselves.

We see that all the Greek city-states had theaters. Why? Because this worldview only applied to free people, you see. Let's not forget that slavery also existed at that time. However, today, thanks to the new technologies you mentioned, such an opportunity is available to everyone.

So what does Bodrunov strives to achieve? He hopes that through the development of a new generation of industrial society (he calls it NIS.2, or "New Industrial Society of the Second Generation"), automation, and sensor technologies, we will be able to create a less polluting industry, meaning one with a smaller impact on the environment. This is entirely possible, but the goal here is not to increase GDP.

If we could live with roughly the same resources but work less, we'd be back to hackneyed slogans that nonetheless had some basis: everyone working and working less - it all makes sense. People should find meaning in what they do.

After all, if we look at the ideas of Peter Thiel and visionaries like Schwab, we see a worldview that frightens me: a small group of people working 80-100 hours a week, while a vast majority of people are effectively useless. They're paid a minimum wage only because, at this point, we lack the courage to tell them outright that they're useless and should be eliminated. In fact, noonomy has a different goal: human fulfillment through work. You're working now, right? Your work benefits not only the economy but also society. For example, Sandro Teti is a publisher; he sells books, which means he participates in economic exchange. But beyond selling books and participating in economic exchange, he provides something important to the people who read them. This is the true task of economics: to satisfy people's material needs, but also to provide them with something that enriches them intellectually and culturally. That's why I would repeat: after many years spent in an intellectual wilderness, I became truly captivated by this book when Sandro Teti introduced me to it. Believe me, over forty years I have read quite a lot of books on economics, and they all extolled individualism and selfishness. Now we see what kind of society forty years of the cult of individualism and selfishness have led us to.

Luca Placidi: Yes, absolutely. Incidentally, I'd like to point out that the book is written in a truly clear and understandable style. I mean, even someone with no background in economics, like me, can easily understand it.

When I started reading this book on noonomy, as I said at the beginning, the first thing that struck me was that it represented yet another original Russian thought.

Because if we really want to look at something, then, oddly enough, we can only look at Russia. Russia seemingly still offers this unique worldview, and this, in my view, is what distinguishes it from cultures like ours: young cultures still look to the future, while ours no longer see it. This is why, paradoxically, we are no longer able to look to the future. We resemble an old, fading man standing on the verge of death. All we can do is look back on the past and be proud of what? The abstract concepts of democracy and human rights that we once exported and continue to export to this day? At the same time, we don't attempt to understand these phenomena in their historical context or consider how to implement these principles, how to develop them further, how to move forward based on a constructive worldview. Meanwhile, constructive worldviews remain preserved only in the East - in China and Russia. And Russia, beyond doubt, continues to create true masterpieces.

Sandro Teti: Getting back on our topic and Bodrunov, I'd like to say first of all: yes, you're absolutely right in noting that we're experiencing creative and ideological sterility. There are no new ideas, and for several decades now, we've been in a state of intellectual atrophy. However, I wouldn't limit this to Russia alone. There are China and some other countries where, unfortunately, this approach is rare, but where people don't focus on day-to-day tasks and don't limit themselves to planning for the next few months. They're trying to look decades into the future and understand development in all its dimensions: human, economic, and more. And here I discovered something that truly intrigued me. Although I frequently visit Russia and closely follow its developments, I hadn't heard of this new economic theory before. Then I met its author - and was completely captivated.

Who is Bodrunov? Where was he born?

Bodrunov grew up in a very modest family, and he still continues to search for what you just mentioned, Giorgio: he strives to give meaning to his life and never rests on his laurels. He made a huge fortune, but not only did he never buy yachts or private jets, he never even used them. He constantly invests in the development of culture and science. His personality made a strong impression on me. I don't understand everything and can't pretend to be an economics expert. I'm familiar with the basics of his theory, but I can't analyze or comment on it in detail. Meanwhile, our publishing house has already released five books on this theory.

I'd like to conclude by recalling another outstanding Belarusian, Nobel laureate Zhores Alferov, with whom I had the opportunity to collaborate. He received the Nobel Prize in Physics and was elected to the State Duma for many terms as a representative of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation. Where was he from? He was from Vitebsk, the birthplace of Marc Chagall. He, too, came from a very poor family and always told me, "Sandro, if I'd been born in America or Western Europe, I would never have won a Nobel Prize or even gotten an education." His path was in many ways similar to Bodrunov's: thanks to his success at school, he was sent to study in Minsk, and from there to Leningrad. There, he was among the best students and, while still very young, developed solar panels that were installed on the first Soviet spacecraft, and so on. This is not about idealizing the Soviet Union: both Bodrunov and Alferov noted its shortcomings, but at the same time emphasized the strengths of the Soviet system, which, in their opinion, and in my opinion too, would be worth using in our society.

In general, I wanted to talk about the people themselves, because behind these theories are real people, people with their own destinies. And I also want to add something. Giorgio was a real discovery for me and at the same time a big surprise. I was struck by the attention he paid to all the Italian-language texts on this theory. Then he came up with a truly brilliant idea: to write a book, a kind of summary, that would introduce this theory to people in simple language, without any special economic training. After all, this theory isn't just new - it's still in its infancy. How does Bodrunov try to make it useful? By putting it into practice.

Luca Placidi: Certainly, any theory needs to be put into practice, but the transition from theory to practice is the most difficult task. However, I see one important distinction here. Unlike the Western world - for example, Europe and America - the East has states, such as Russia and, of course, China, which proceed from the opposite principle: the economy should not rule the world and determine the political course. Everything should be the other way around. Fortunately, there are still states where it is politics - and therefore the life of the republic and concern for the common good, to use this term, or at least the striving for this good - that determines the direction of economic development so that this common good can become a reality.

I believe, this book and the theory it presents are part of an attempt to shape a different vision of the world. Today, we often hear, including from representatives of the most radical left, that the question of revolution and the seizure of power must be brought back to the center of the discussion.  In my opinion, such reasoning is completely divorced from reality: currently there are neither the material conditions nor the corresponding balance of forces that would allow us to seriously reason in such a manner.

I believe our Western society would do well to reintroduce critical thinking to the center of public debate and, above all, begin to rethink, reimagine, and theorize the future. This doesn't necessarily mean the future must be revolutionary, modeled on the 20th century: the experience of the 20th century belongs to the 20th century itself.

Today, technology is advancing, and its development should serve humanity, not work against it, as is currently the case. Therefore, in my view, studying such economic theories and addressing the questions they raise means offering future generations a perspective that could help them overcome the extreme individualism deeply ingrained in Western society. We've become so accustomed to it that we perceive it as completely natural.

My sincere thanks to Sandro and Giorgio. See you next time! Perhaps we can continue our conversation next time, and, of course, thanks to all our listeners. Thank you, and have a good evening everyone!

Giorgio Brera, Sandro Teti: Thank you, thank you!

Giorgio Brera: Thank you, everybody! Thank you all!


About 24 minutes

Video from the interview

Sergey Bodrunov’s book “Noonomy” discussed on Tracce di Classe podcast
Tracce di Classe podcast on Sergey Bodrunov’s book “Noonomy” · WAN